Thicknesser: When To Upgrade and When To Buy New

Upgrading Your Thicknesser: Should You Buy a New Thicknesser or Just Upgrade to a Spiral Helical Cutterhead?

When it comes to enhancing your woodworking setup, one of the key decisions you'll face is whether to invest in a new thicknesser or simply upgrade your existing machine with a helical spiral cutter head. Each option has its own set of advantages and considerations. In this article, we'll explore the factors to weigh when making your decision and why upgrading to a helical spiral cutter head might be the smarter choice for many woodworkers.

Understanding Your Options

1. Buying a New Thicknesser:

  • Advantages:
    • Enhanced Features: Newer thicknessers often come with advanced features such as digital readouts, improved feed systems, and enhanced dust collection capabilities.
    • Updated Technology: Modern machines may incorporate the latest technological advancements, offering better precision, efficiency, and ease of use.
    • Manufacturer Warranty: A new machine typically comes with a full warranty, providing peace of mind and protection against defects or issues.
  • Considerations:
    • Cost: Purchasing a new thicknesser is a significant investment. The cost can range from several hundred to several thousand dollars, depending on the machine's features and brand.
    • Space: A new thicknesser may require additional space in your workshop. Ensure you have adequate room to accommodate a larger machine.
    • Learning Curve: Transitioning to a new machine may involve a learning curve as you adjust to its controls, features, and setup.

2. Upgrading to a Spiral Helical Cutterhead:

  • Advantages:
    • Improved Cut Quality: Spiral Helical cutterheads provide superior surface finishes with minimal tear-out and snipe. Their design creates a shearing effect that results in smoother cuts, reducing the need for extensive sanding.
    • Reduced Noise: These cutter heads are significantly quieter than traditional straight knives, creating a more pleasant working environment.
    • Lower Maintenance: Helical spiral cutterheads use carbide inserts that can be rotated to utilize multiple cutting edges. This extends the lifespan of the inserts and reduces the frequency of blade replacements and sharpening.
    • Cost-Effective: Upgrading your existing thicknesser with a helical spiral cutter head is often more affordable than purchasing a new machine. It also allows you to retain the functionality of your current equipment while enhancing its performance.
  • Considerations:
    • Compatibility: Ensure that the helical spiral cutter head is compatible with your thicknesser model. Some machines may require specific sizes or configurations.
    • Installation: Installing a helical spiral cutter head may require some technical knowledge. If you're not comfortable with the installation process, you might need professional assistance.
    • Incremental Improvement: While a helical spiral cutter head offers significant improvements in cut quality and noise reduction, it may not provide the same level of technological advancements or additional features found in a new machine.

Making the Decision: Factors to Consider

1. Current Machine Performance:

Assess the performance and condition of your current thicknesser. If it still functions well but lacks the cutting quality and efficiency you desire, upgrading to a helical spiral cutter head could be a cost-effective solution. Conversely, if your machine is outdated or experiencing frequent issues, investing in a new thicknesser might be a more prudent choice.

2. Budget:

Determine your budget for the upgrade. A spiral helical cutterhead typically costs significantly less than a new thicknesser. If you're looking to improve cut quality without a substantial investment, upgrading the cutter head is an attractive option. However, if you have the budget and are interested in additional features and modern technology, a new thicknesser might be worth the investment.

3. Workshop Space:

Consider the available space in your workshop. A new thicknesser may require more room than your existing machine, while upgrading to a helical spiral cutter head does not involve additional space requirements.

4. Long-Term Goals:

Reflect on your long-term woodworking goals. If you plan to expand your workshop or take on more demanding projects, a new thicknesser with advanced features might better align with your future needs. If your primary goal is to improve the quality of your cuts and reduce noise, a helical spiral cutter head offers a targeted and effective upgrade.

Conclusion

Deciding between buying a new thicknesser or upgrading to a spiral helical cutterhead depends on your specific needs, budget, and long-term goals. For many woodworkers, upgrading to a helical spiral cutterhead offers an excellent balance of improved performance and cost-effectiveness. It enhances cut quality, reduces noise, and simplifies maintenance while preserving the functionality of your existing equipment. However, if you're looking for a complete overhaul with the latest features and technology, investing in a new thicknesser might be the right choice. Evaluate your options carefully, and choose the solution that best aligns with your woodworking aspirations and workshop requirements.

Back to blog